Descriptive Result of Feedback by Concern Type

H2: Personal attitudes (positivity, stimulation, and you may public engdecadesment) is seriously pertaining to the new assessment (appropriateness, respected, and approved out of) away from confident attitude in Westerners and East Asians.

H3: New feeling–assessment relationships differs along the two social teams. Specifically, to have Westerners, brand new positivity (3a) and you can pleasure (3b) out of self-confident feelings be more highly connected with sensed social critiques, and also for East Asians, perceptions off societal engagement be highly related to public recommendations (3c).


An a priori power calculation for repeated measures, between-factors MANOVA showed that a total of 386 participants was needed to obtain power of 0.95, ? error probability = 0.00036 (Bonferroni corrected), correlation among repeated measures = 0.1, at an expected small effect size 0.1. A total of 244 students from Hong Kong (nman = 113, ngirl = 122, Prefer not to say = 9) and 253 students from Netherlands (nman = 122, nwoman = 129, Prefer not to say = 2) took part. There was no difference in gender distribution across groups, Chi-square = 4.83, p = 0.09. Hong Kong Chinese participants (Meanage = , SDage = 2.11) on average were 1 year younger than Dutch participants (Meanage = , SDage = 3.59), t(424) = ?3.93, p 2 .

Analysis Planning

We utilized Roentgen studio step 3.1 to possess analysis data. We first needed to handle to have potential differences in the ways that people in both cultural organizations explore score bills and you will, therefore, conducted within this-people standardization into a couple groups ). For each people, i basic deducted brand new huge imply (this new imply all over all of the situations and all sorts of some body on the class) out of per reaction and then split they by huge standard deviation (the standard departure across the every things and other people for the reason that group). Participants’ judgments for each of your own 23 positive feelings are listed when you look at the Second Dining tables 2, 3 (intense scores) and you will (fixed getting social reaction biases). Schadenfreude (the feeling out of viewing some thing bad happening to a different person) wasn’t rated because a confident feelings while it match all of our definition: dos.89 (Hong-kong Chinese) and you can 3.18 (Dutch) for the a great 9-point level that have four as the midpoint and 9 becoming maximally self-confident. Ergo, it was excluded away from further data analysis; the latest analysis off schadenfreude was in fact therefore not utilized for calculating this new huge imply and you may grand important departure.

Ahead of the theory screening, i report new detailed outcome of the fresh new half dozen questions having Hong Kong and Netherlands. For these analyses, we averaged the brand new studies round the the twenty-two thoughts for each and every class. We computed Cronbach’s alpha per of half dozen questions getting Hong kong and you can Netherlands, by themselves. The alpha beliefs have been more than 0.86, indicating a precision (discover Secondary Table 4A). The typical studies for each and every matter type in for every single nation try said in Supplementary Desk 4B.

Theory Testing

H1: We first checked out the H1 that there might be social feel to have pleasure critiques and you can social differences toward most other four types away from feedback towards emotion recommendations. I then went multivariate regression activities half dozen minutes inside the for each model, utilizing the nation due to the fact predictor and you may critiques for all self-confident emotions while the outcomes (age.grams., the newest arousal recommendations for everybody 22 emotions). For every single model, i basic checked out the fresh multivariate impression towards the twenty-two attitude just like the a team in relation to nation (Second Desk 5A); i up coming looked at the nation-feeling score relationship for every feeling. Because there was twenty-two thinking once the outcome parameters, from inside the for every single model, the new p-worthy of are fixed for several reviews with the Bonferroni-Holm method (said in the Supplementary Table 5B).

The multivariate show demonstrate that, for everybody half dozen evaluations, including the pleasure feedback, there had been clear social distinctions. As opposed to our hypothesis you to definitely Hong-kong Chinese and you will Dutch users create price thoughts also getting arousal, we unearthed that self-confident thinking was in fact rated since the higher into the stimulation in the Hong-kong than in Netherlands. When it comes to certain ideas, awe, gratitude, moved, tender, and you will success have been mathematically ranked alot more naughty from the Hong-kong professionals than simply Dutch professionals. Additional thoughts was in fact ranked furthermore along side a couple regions.